People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Atmosphere was better back before they cleaned it up. Miss all the stuff, but food is good. Crust is slightly different than it used to be ”
“ While there's only like, two options in town, this is the closest to a 'legit' New York slice experience you're gonna get. No shade to the other place, but you can at least stand outside The Slice and pretend, for a moment, you're in a walkable city with all the things you need within a few blocks. The pizza is consistently solid and genuinely beats out some places in New York I've had recommended to me in the past. The staff is quick and friendly. The vibe is very much "your uncle's favorite dive sports bar but they serve pizza", it almost feels like a CBS sitcom set from the cashier back. As a former USI student I will cop to the preppy overpriced U of E education having one thing over USI: Their students can walk to The Slice. ”
“ Me and my boys came 10 mins before closing because we thought it closed at 11pm. But John was kind enough to take our order. Best pizza in town!!! and also shoutout to Ashley for giving us 2 free slices of pizza! 10/10 food, 10/10 service, and 11/10 atmosphere! ”
“ really love the Slice - especially the new layout! same great pizza with a few new twists and variations! have always liked the Slice, but the new renovations under the new owner and his team are fantastic! the place is more spacious, plenty of room and you can catch a game on one of their several tv’s! the place is clean and the service is excellent and friendly! fantastic pizza, great prices, great atmosphere! try it!! ”
“ What a great place. They literally serve by the slice and cooked fresh. With many options to choose from in this very friendly comfortable atmosphere. A great place!!! ”
“ Awesome pizza the cheese that is used is amazing so many options but the traditional cheese, sausage, pepperoni tend to be what all of my family gets. The sauce is always perfect never overly heavy and never dried out. We go here once a week and everyone loves it kids and adults both!! It is cash only. ”
“ Love The Slice! Ordered the chicken and chili pizzas and both were amazing. Highly recommend checking it out if you’re in the area. ”
“ This place is awesome! Great pizza with an amazing vibe. My daughter & I tried 5 or 6 different slices. I liked the pesto slice the best. Rhett liked the gyro slice the best. Tough call! UPDATE: it has been sold to a new owner. ”
Menu
Pizza Buffet
US$14.50Ranch
US$28.00Side Of Tzatziki
US$0.50Chips
US$1.50Grippo's
US$2.00
About
The Slice
Welcome to The Slice, your ultimate destination for pizza lovers in Evansville, Indiana! Nestled at 2011 Lincoln Ave, this pizza haven is redefining the bite-sized joy of enjoying a slice while offering a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. With a phone call away at +1 812-454-0983, indulging in delightful flavors has never been easier!
At The Slice, pizza is not just a meal; it's an experience. Their diverse menu boasts a tantalizing array of options that everyone's taste buds can appreciate. Treat yourself to the Spinach Cheese Slice, a harmonious blend of spinach, garlic, feta, and oil for just US$3.75. If you’re a purist at heart, the classic Cheese Slice with rich red sauce is a wallet-friendly delight at US$3.00.
Looking to try something inventive? Don't miss the Ranch Slice, layered with savory homemade ranch, onions, and fresh tomato slices, or the hearty Potato Slice topped with baked potatoes, mozzarella, and a drizzle of tzatziki for a full culinary experience—all priced around US$3.75! And for those craving a comforting classic, the Gyro Slice is sure to hit the spot with its medley of cheese, gyro, and bell peppers.
The dining experience doesn’t stop there! The Slice also offers tantalizing Pizza Buffets, allowing you to enjoy any four of their award-winning slices paired with your favorite soda for just US$14.50. It’s perfect for a fulfilling lunch or a casual dinner with friends. The convenience of grab-and-go slices means you can savor your meal on the move or settle in for the evening.
With reviews echoing the charm of The Slice, patrons like Gavin Gaddis note it’s “the closest to a 'legit' New York slice experience” in town. Meanwhile, the revamped atmosphere under new ownership has turned many first-time visitors into loyal fans, as highlighted by Rod Summers. Customers rave about the clean layout, friendly service, and the warm vibe that ushers in great conversations over delicious slices.
Whether you are a local or just passing through, The Slice promises friendly service and pizza that not only satisfies your hunger but also warms your heart. Join the community at The Slice and discover why it’s more than a pizzeria—it’s where flavor meets friendship!
Book a table